Efficacy of Combinational Treatment versus Nicotinamide Monotherapy in the Prevention of Ultraviolet Radiation-Induced Skin Cancer

Abstract

Introduction: Ultraviolet radiation (UVR) is the primary risk factor for keratinocyte carcinomas. Oral supplementation with nicotinamide (NAM) is reported to reduce the formation of new keratinocyte carcinomas. NAM's photoprotection is mediated by enhanced DNA repair. We wanted to explore whether NAM in combination with antiproliferative (metformin [Met]) or antioxidant (phloroglucinol [PG]) compounds could potentially enhance its photoprotective effects.

Methods: Hairless mice (C3.Cg-Hrhr/TifBomTac) were treated orally with either a standard dose of NAM monotherapy (NAM-mono; 600 mg/kg) or NAM (400 mg/kg) combined with Met (200 mg/kg) (NAM-Met) or PG (75 mg/kg) (NAM-PG). Mice were irradiated with 3.5 standard erythema doses of UVR three times per week to induce tumour development. Photoprotective effects were based on (i) tumour onset of the first three tumours, (ii) skin photodamage, and (iii) DNA damage (cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers [CPDs] and pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproducts [6-4PPs]).

Results: All mice treated with NAM demonstrated a delay in tumour onset and reduced tumour burden compared to the UV control group (NAM, NAM-Met, NAM-PG vs. UV control: p ≤ 0.015). NAM-mono and NAM-PG increased time until all three tumours with no difference between them, indicating a similar degree of photoprotection. NAM-mono had no effect on DNA damage compared to the UV control group (p > 0.05), whereas NAM-PG reduced 6-4PP lesions (p < 0.01) but not CPDs (p > 0.05) compared to NAM-mono. NAM-Met delayed the onset of the third tumour compared to the UV control but demonstrated a quicker onset compared to NAM-mono, suggesting inferior photoprotection compared to nicotinamide monotherapy.

Conclusion: NAM-PG was as effective in delaying UVR-induced tumour onset as NAM-mono. The reduction in 6-4PP lesions may indicate that the mechanism of NAM-PG is better suited for photoprotection than NAM-mono. NAM-mono was superior to NAM-Met, indicating a dose dependency of NAM's photoprotection. These results highlight the potential for combining photoprotective compounds to enhance photoprotection.